hi, i’m amr. one checkbox in google ads decides whether an audience list limits your search ads or just reports on them, and i still see accounts where it was set the wrong way and nobody noticed. google’s help page on the two settings is clear about what each does.
what google says, in its own words
- “Targeting restricts the reach of your ad group.” it covers display and video keywords, placements, topics, demographics and audiences
- “The “Observation” setting won’t change who can see your ads or where they can show.”
- observation “allows you to monitor and set custom bids for criteria without restricting your reach”
- for search and shopping campaigns, google recommends observation for audiences
- for display, “Targeting is recommended for all advertisers in their Display campaigns”, with observation suggested for more advanced display advertisers
- google suggests you “set up your targeting based on the results of your observation”
- with smart bidding, first-party audience segments added under observation are used as signals for the bid strategy
- demographics use the targeting setting, and by default all demographic groups are targeted
- you can’t add an observation method when you first create an ad group
- display and video keywords can’t be used in observation mode
the page doesn’t warn how much reach drops if you switch a search audience to targeting, doesn’t say whether data carries over when you switch, and doesn’t explain how manual bid adjustments interact with smart bidding.
my reading, not google’s wording: on a search campaign, an audience set to targeting quietly turns a keyword campaign into a remarketing campaign. that can be what you want, but it should be a decision, not a default someone clicked.
what to check this week
- open each search and shopping ad group with audiences attached and note whether each segment is on targeting or observation
- if a segment is on targeting, ask whether you meant to limit those ads to that list only. if not, google’s recommendation for search is observation
- for display, check the opposite: an ad group with no targeting method can run anywhere on the web within your campaign settings
- if you use smart bidding, add your first-party lists under observation so the bid strategy can use them as signals
- after a few weeks, read the audience report and decide whether any segment earns its own campaign. google’s page suggests targeting based on what observation shows
- if you added customer match lists, my earlier post on customer match covers when memberships expire
where this stops applying
performance max and some newer campaign types handle audiences as signals and don’t use this ad group setting in the same way. the page gives no reach figures, and i haven’t audited any account for this post.
start scaling — if nobody on your team can say which audiences on your search campaigns are limiting reach, a one-hour review of the settings will show it. let’s connect.
Sources: Google Ads Help, “About ‘Targeting’ and ‘Observation’ settings” (support.google.com/google-ads/answer/7365594). Figures are published product documentation, not verified results from Amr’s own client accounts.